Just this Saturday evening, a Facebook page was created by an anonymous Paul VI High School student called, “PVI on Blast,” which aired the dirty laundry of more than forty students. Both boys and girls were defamed for a variety of reasons, including race and sexual orientation.
In this technology-crazed generation, problems are handled over the internet. Days of face to face confrontation seem to be long gone. We have entered an age where it’s much easier to tell the world of Facebook how terrible someone is and expose all of their secrets to millions of people. But should typing the word ‘slut’ after someone’s name be taken into legal matters? Or are we protected by our First Amendment regarding the freedom of speech?
On January 5 of this year, New Jersey governor, Chris Christie, signed the nation’s toughest anti-bullying law in the nation which went into effect on September 1. Hoping to reduce the risks of suicide, initially for gay and lesbian teens, the new law requires public schools to discuss bullying with their students. The law also states that any administrator who does not report incidents of bullying that take place inside or outside of the school will be disciplined, and any student who partakes in bullying could be suspended or expelled.
Paul VI junior, Dominick Santersiero, talks about being a victim of the “PVI on Blast” harassment. “My first thoughts on seeing my name on there were a mix of surprise and laughter because I didn’t really expect anyone to think of me like that.” And of course the question that no one can wrap their minds around is why anyone would go out of their way to make more than forty people feel horrible about themselves. “It’s just really wrong in my eyes… the person must either have something wrong with them or they are just looking for attention.”
It’s no doubt that there are instances of bullying that should be taken more seriously than others , such as the things written on PVI on Blast this weekend. Nowadays, however, you have to walk on eggshells around these anti-bullying laws. The KKK has the right to rally with megaphones in front of hundreds of spectators, and wish death to people because they’re black, but it’s illegal to type your opinions out on Facebook about someone you don’t like. In no way shape or form should bullying or someone’s negative speech be condoned, but there is a definite unbalanced line that has been drawn between bullying being legal and illegal. Everyone’s main fear of bullying going too far is the thought of someone killing themselves over it. It seems as though in today’s society, suicide is the solution to many of life’s problems. Victims of bullying are two to nine times more likely to commit suicide than anyone else, according to a study done by Yale University. Suicide is never the answer, and many people believe that instead of teaching kids not to be a bully, maybe we should be teaching our kids how to deal with bullies.
When it comes to bullying, there is and will always be a double standard. On one hand, you are allowed to say whatever you want about someone, because technically it’s your opinion and you have the freedom to voice it. But then you run into the Declaration of Independence which states that every American citizen is entitled to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. It’s obvious that when you say negative things about someone, it infringes upon their right to happiness. To protect someone from being bullied, you’d have to take away someone’s right to speak their opinions. But to protect someone’s freedom of speech, you would be taking away another person’s right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. And who decides which is more important?
Officials are trying to find the culprit behind this chaos caused at Paul VI. When they do, whether you agree with it or not, the person will be in the hands of the law. No matter what happens, the kids at Paul VI have, hopefully, learned a lesson. Anyone can be a victim of bullying, and no one feels good about it afterwards.


